When my son was in pre-school, I got a few calls that he was
having issues with another child, some of them escalating to them hitting each
other. One day I got a “note” pinned to my sign in/out sheet addressed to my 3
year old, who, while this might categorize him as an underachieving child by
perfect parent standards, could not read.
I read the note and it was basically about needing to be friends with
everyone in the class. I discussed the
issue with my son, took away toys, gave him alternative behaviors, tried to get
him to stop. The issues continued, so I
made an appointment to sit in on the class for the morning. I discovered two children who just plain old
didn’t like each other. Their
personalities were vastly different, and though they were interested in the
same toys, they clearly didn’t want to play with them together.
I’ll admit, I patted myself on the back a little for not
reading the not to my son, not only because I thought it was strange to write a
note at 3-year old level when you clearly know only the parent can read it, but
because I had that “a-ha!” moment when I thought I realized what the real issue
was. I sat my son down and talked to him
about it again.
“Aiden, I can see that you don’t like “J”. I can see that “J” doesn’t like you. And you know what? That is OK.”
“But the teacher says we have to be friends.”
Yep, I nailed it.
“No, no, no, no, UM, no.
You do not ever HAVE to be someone’s friend. You have to be nice to everyone. You need to be respectful to everyone. You do
not have to like them. They do not have
to like you. You do NOT have to be friends. That is normal. People are all different and sometimes people
don’t get along, and that is perfectly OK.
If someone doesn’t like you, it doesn’t mean there is something wrong
with you, or there is something wrong with them. It is up to you to decide who is your friend.”
As adults, we tend to turn “We all have to be friends” into “You
can’t make judgments!” We mean the same
thing. And we’re wrong.
First of all, I’m not sure how someone makes it through the
day without making any judgments. A judgment
is “the ability to judge, make a
decision, or form an opinion objectively, authoritatively, and wisely,
especially in matters affecting action; good sense; discretion.” It’s what we mean when we tell our kids “Make
good choices.” We decide what to wear
based on judgments about the weather and the occasion. We decide what to eat based on what we like
or what we find to be healthy (and determining what is healthy is also a judgment.) We decide when to turn into traffic, where we
allow our child to do something, when we select the TV show that evening for
our family, all based on judgments.
Every single one.
When we decide
who we want our children to have a playdate with, who we want to date, who we
want to marry, or even who we want to hang out with for the evening based on
judgments. And that is OK. We are allowed to like who we want and
dislike who we want, and they can be for the stupidest reasons ever. I actually like most people, even those vastly different than me, but there are people I don’t like because they
have been repeatedly rude to me, there
are people I don’t like because they are obnoxious, there are people I don’t
like because they are irresponsible, and there are people I don’t like just
because their laugh annoys the crap out of me.
But I am nice, and I am respectful, and that is all I need to be.
There are
people that don’t like me because I’m too quiet, too opinionated, because because
I don’t suck up to them, or I didn’t use cloth diapers.. And that is OK too.
It’s OK to
express your opinion, even when it is not the popular one. It’s OK to be who you are, even if someone
else calls you a name for it. It’s OK
for people to not like you, as long as you truly like yourself. It’s even OK to tell someone you don’t agree
with them or with their behavior, but you have to realize that the “OK” stops
there, it is up to them to judge if they are OK with their life, beliefs,
values, and opinions, or if they want to change them. We can’t make everyone agree, and, if you ask
me, that is an awesome thing. Utopia
would be a bit boring too me.
That’s why they
have wine. Or beer, or orange juice, or
Pepsi, or water, whatever your choice is.
And by the way, my son never had the hitting problems after that conversation. It really is easier to understand that someone may not like you than it is to try to force them to.
And by the way, my son never had the hitting problems after that conversation. It really is easier to understand that someone may not like you than it is to try to force them to.